By 
Short answer: the Duck Treat Dispenser is the better pick if you want a toy that stays put while your dog works. It has non-slip pads and two suction cups, three challenge lids, is waterproof and hand-washable, and has a 30-day money-back guarantee. The Dog Smart is a solid Level 1 board puzzle, but its page does not mention any grip.
The Nina Ottosson Dog Smart by Outward Hound is one of the first puzzles people search for when they want a treat toy for a beginner dog. Our Duck Treat Dispenser is built for the same job, rewarding a dog for working out how to get a treat. The two work very differently, and the differences matter for how long they hold your dog’s interest.
Dog Smart vs Duck Treat Dispenser at a glance
| Feature | Pets Sparkle Duck Treat Dispenser | Outward Hound Dog Smart |
|---|---|---|
| How treats are released | ✓Press the duck’s tail and a treat dispenses | ✓Lift removable bone covers to find treats in nine hidden compartments |
| Difficulty | ✓3 challenge lids to make it harder over time | ✓Adjustable: raise the bones or leave them flat (Level 1) |
| Grip on the floor | ✓Non-slip pads and 2 suction cups | –Not mentioned on the product page |
| Materials | ✓BPA-free PP and ABS | ✓Food-safe composite, free from BPA, PVC and phthalates |
| Cleaning | ✓Waterproof and hand-washable | ✓Cleans easily with warm water and mild soap |
| Dog size | ✓All breeds and kibble sizes | ✓Any breed and size |
| Guarantee | ✓30-day money-back guarantee | –None stated on the pages we reviewed |
Checkmark means yes, cross means no, dash means the product page does not say. Rival details are taken from the sources listed at the bottom of this page.
Where the Duck Treat Dispenser comes out ahead
- It stays in place. Non-slip pads plus two suction cups mean a keen dog does not push the toy across the floor. The Dog Smart page does not mention any grip features.
- It is a dispenser, not a hide-and-seek board. Pressing the tail rewards a dog right away, which keeps a beginner motivated.
- It grows with your dog. Three challenge lids let you raise the difficulty without buying a new toy.
- It is easy to rinse. The Duck is waterproof and hand-washable, so cleaning is a quick rinse.
- It comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Where the Dog Smart fits
The Dog Smart is a well-known Level 1 puzzle with nine hidden compartments and adjustable difficulty, and Outward Hound says it suits any breed and size. If your dog loves lifting covers to hunt for hidden treats, it is a fair choice. Its page also asks you to supervise and not let your dog chew the pieces, so check the pieces after each session.
Which one should you choose?
Choose the Duck Treat Dispenser if
- You want a treat toy that stays put on the floor
- You want something that gets harder as your dog improves
- You want a simple rinse-clean toy with a 30-day guarantee
Choose the Dog Smart if
- Your dog enjoys lifting covers to find hidden treats
- You want a board-style Level 1 puzzle with removable pieces
Is it worth switching?
If grip, easy cleaning and room to grow matter to you, yes. The Duck Treat Dispenser gives a beginner dog quick rewards and a ladder of harder lids. For more on picking one, read our guide to the dog treat dispenser toy and our comparison of interactive dog puzzle toys.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Nina Ottosson Dog Smart better than the Duck Treat Dispenser?
We think the Duck Treat Dispenser is the better pick for most owners: it has non-slip pads and two suction cups, three challenge lids, a waterproof body and a 30-day guarantee. The Dog Smart is a good board-style beginner puzzle if your dog likes lifting covers.
Is the Dog Smart safe for dogs that chew?
Outward Hound says to always supervise, not let your dog chew the toy or its pieces, and to inspect it for damage. The same sensible rule applies to any puzzle toy.
What size dog is the Duck Treat Dispenser for?
All breeds and kibble sizes.
Is the Duck Treat Dispenser easy to clean?
Yes. It is waterproof and hand-washable.
Sources (links checked October 2026)
Outward Hound and Nina Ottosson are trademarks of their respective owners. Pets Sparkle is not affiliated with or endorsed by Outward Hound. Competitor details come from the public pages listed above and can change, so check the current listing before you buy.
Mahmoud Mohamed Samir is an SEO/GEO Specialist who turns veterinary research into clear, practical feeding guides, built so pet parents get straight answers whether they search on Google or ask an AI assistant.
View all articles by Mahmoud
