By 
Short answer: for a small dog or a cat, the Pawzzle Feeder Ball is the better pick. It is natural rubber, made for small dogs and cats, and has a 30-day money-back guarantee. The Treat Tumble is plastic, comes in Small and Large, and is listed for dogs.
The Treat Tumble by Outward Hound is a popular rolling treat ball, so it is the one many owners compare against when they shop for a small-dog treat ball. Our Pawzzle Feeder Ball is a natural rubber ball made specifically for small dogs and cats. Size is the key safety point with any ball toy, so this comparison starts there.
Treat Tumble vs Pawzzle Feeder Ball at a glance
| Feature | Pets Sparkle Pawzzle Feeder Ball | Outward Hound Treat Tumble |
|---|---|---|
| Material | ✓Natural rubber | –Food-safe BPA-free plastic |
| Size | ✓4.7 x 4.7 x 4.4 cm (about 1.9 in) | –Small and Large sizes. Dimensions are not listed on the product page |
| Pets | ✓Small dogs and cats | –Dogs. No cat guidance on the page |
| Size guidance | ✓Clear: made for small dogs and cats, and a choking hazard for medium and large dogs | –Two sizes, but no weight or breed guidance on the product page |
| Colors | ✓Sky blue or green | –Varies by size |
| Guarantee | ✓30-day money-back guarantee | –None stated on the pages we reviewed |
Checkmark means yes, cross means no, dash means the product page does not say. Rival details are taken from the sources listed at the bottom of this page.
Where the Pawzzle Feeder Ball comes out ahead
- Natural rubber has a softer feel than a plastic ball.
- It is made for small dogs and cats, so a cat can play with it too.
- We tell you plainly who it is for. It is small, so it is a choking hazard for medium and large dogs and should not be used by them.
- It comes in two colors and with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Where the Treat Tumble fits
The Treat Tumble is a Level 1 treat ball with two treat holes, and it comes in a Large size, so it covers bigger dogs than our ball does. If your dog is medium or large, our Pawzzle Feeder Ball is too small for safe use, so choose a larger ball instead. For small dogs and cats, ours is the better fit.
Which one should you choose?
Choose the Pawzzle Feeder Ball if
- You have a small dog or a cat
- You want a soft natural rubber ball
- You want clear size guidance and a 30-day guarantee
Choose the Treat Tumble if
- You have a medium or large dog and want a larger ball
- You want a Level 1 plastic ball with two treat holes
Is it worth switching?
For a small dog or cat, yes. The Pawzzle Feeder Ball is sized for them and made of natural rubber. Read our guide to the treat ball for small dogs for how to fill and introduce it, and our best slow feeder for small dogs guide for a bowl to pair it with.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Outward Hound Treat Tumble better than the Pawzzle Feeder Ball?
For small dogs and cats we think the Pawzzle Feeder Ball is the better pick: natural rubber, made for small pets and backed by a 30-day guarantee. The Treat Tumble offers a Large size for bigger dogs, which our ball does not.
Can a medium or large dog use the Pawzzle Feeder Ball?
No. It is about 1.9 inches across and is a choking hazard for medium and large dogs. Choose a larger ball for them.
What is the Treat Tumble made of?
Outward Hound’s product page says food-safe, BPA-free plastic with no PVC or phthalates.
Can cats play with the Pawzzle Feeder Ball?
Yes. It is made for small dogs and cats.
Sources (links checked October 2026)
- Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound Treat Tumble Interactive Puzzle Dog Toy, Small Outward Hound
- Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound Treat Tumble (Chewy) Chewy
Outward Hound and Nina Ottosson are trademarks of their respective owners. Pets Sparkle is not affiliated with or endorsed by Outward Hound. Competitor details come from the public pages listed above and can change, so check the current listing before you buy.
Mahmoud Mohamed Samir is an SEO/GEO Specialist who turns veterinary research into clear, practical feeding guides, built so pet parents get straight answers whether they search on Google or ask an AI assistant.
View all articles by Mahmoud
